Under the Dome

Senate tentatively OKs boards & commissions bill, despite concerns about getting rid of judges

The Senate on Wednesday tentatively approved the bill that would give Republican legislators and the GOP governor the power to remove all members of several key boards and commissions and replace them with their own choices.

Republicans agreed to take another day for the final vote.

The approval along party lines came despite warnings from Democrats that the bill could be unconstitutional because the General Assembly is not allowed to remove individual judges from office. Republicans said it's OK to eliminate the positions of 12 special superior court judges, who often travel around the state to hear cases.

The GOP lawmakers said they've heard those judges don't have much of a workload. They also want judges to be elected from local districts and not appointed to serve statewide.

Here's a look at who those judges are, thanks to The N&O's Andy Curliss:

These judges are all indeed special — they were not elected, but were all appointed by past governors. Some were first appointed by one governor, and then continued under a subsequent governor with a reappointment.

As special judges, they could be assigned to any Superior Court case across the state. They would hold regular court, help with special hearings, step in to help other judges avoid conflicts, and otherwise were assigned to alleviate backlogs or cover for absences.

They are paid $125,875 a year with another $62,372 in benefits and travel allowance.

And four of the 12 were made judges in the final hours of the terms of former Democratic governors Mike Easley and Bev Perdue.

Easley appointed Shannon Joseph, who is the daughter-in-law of former Senate majority leader Tony Rand and was an administrative law judge, and Bill Pittman, who was in private practice, on his last day in office. They were sworn in at 11 p.m. by a judge who was on his way to Perdue's inaugural ball in 2009.

Perdue left office on Jan. 5 this year, but did not take substantial action after Dec. 31.

That was the day that Perdue appointed as special judges both her secretary of the Department of Public Safety, Reuben Young, and Kendra Hill, who was her chief ethics officer and deputy counsel. Young had previously been a close adviser to Easley. Neither had judicial experience.

Of the other eight, one is overseeing a case now involving Republican Sen. Fletcher Hartsell Jr. That judge's term expires later this month, though the judges typically remain in place until a successor is picked or they are reappointed.

Hartsell rose on the Senate floor Wednesday and raised concerns about the judge cutting, saying he thought it was in violation of the state Constitution. He did not mention that a special judge was handling his ongoing case. Others said he was not reading the Constitution correctly.

Another of the special judges is overseeing a lawsuit brought by former District Attorney Tracey Cline against The News & Observer.

Here is the full list of judges on the block, according to the state courts system:

1. Reuben Young (Wake County), appointed Dec. 31, 2012. Term expires Dec. 31, 2017.

2. Kendra Hill (Wake County), appointed Dec. 31, 2012. Term expires Dec. 31, 2017.

3. Lane Williamson (Mecklenburg County), appointed Feb. 24, 2011. Term expires Jan. 9, 2013. He is continuing to serve until a new judge is appointed to this slot, officials said.

4. Sharon Barrett (Buncombe County), appointed Feb. 10, 2011. Term expires May 14, 2013.

5. Lucy Inman (Wake County), appointed April 30, 2010. Term expires April 29, 2015.

6. Andrew Robinson Hassell (Guilford County), appointed March 31, 2009. Term expires Jan. 26, 2016.

7. Shannon Joseph (Wake County), appointed Jan. 9, 2009. Term expires Jan. 8, 2014.

8. Bill Pittman (Wake County), appointed Jan. 9, 2009. Term expires Jan. 8, 2014.

9. Jack Hooks (Columbus County), appointed Jan. 9, 2003. Term expires Feb. 7, 2013.

10. Jack Jenkins (Carteret County), appointed Jan. 26, 2001. Term expires Jan. 26, 2016.

11. Gary Trawick (Pender County), appointed April 1, 1999. Term expires Oct. 20, 2015.

12. Richard Doughton (Alleghany County), appointed Aug. 22, 1997. Term expires Feb. 24, 2013.

(This version is updated from the original post.)

1360188338 Senate tentatively OKs boards & commissions bill, despite concerns about getting rid of judges The News and Observer Copyright 2011 The News and Observer . All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Is this what you voted for?

Did you vote for McCrory to remake our state and make himself King of NC. He want's to be like Rick Snyder in Michigan. What is he going to do next, start removing local representatives and appointing Emergency Managers absolute power to do his bidding in every small town and municipality in the State. They are in a hurry to do this before we are in an uproar. And trust me, this is only the beginning. All you are going to hear out of him and GOP/Republican/Tea Party is deadbeat this, cut taxes and spending that, remove, reorganize wasteful this and that... but when you look up, your benefits, pay, SS, unemployment, medicare and medicaid, educational assistance, upward mobility, taxes, fees, interest, insurance, food, gas, utilities, etc will take more out your pockets and you won't know what hit you.

The only interest these people have are increasing the value of their stock portfolios and raiding your savings, 401-Ks, pensions and any other stand alone cash they can get their hands on to line their pockets. McCrory sent the signal when the first thing he did was give his Staff Raises before his Hiney hit the seat in Raleigh.

They are Pathetic and have only scratched the surface of their Ideology and Hypocrisy. Just wait, they'll be Tea'ing up the Voter ID Suppression Crap in a day or two.

Boards and judges lost is a loss to the people of NC

This naked power grab removes all balance from NC Boards and Commissions. Decades of work by people in close communication with each other and the people they discuss detailed factors with in order to do the work of protecting the citizens of North Carolina will be lost.

The boards are in place to protect North Carolinians, and guide regulations that protect them in the workplace, protect their air and water and land from pollution and sprawl, and keep utility and insurance companies from overcharging.

The Superior Judge positions are needed to clear the dockets of overburdened courts, and will be replaced with 'conservative' judges. Industrial Commission Judges have years of research invested in workplace laws and violations, and workers rights. The working people of North Carolina lose by their firing, and inevitable replacement.

McCrory already has the power to appoint future members and judges, this law is meant to clearly cement the GOP agenda in place immediately, going forward.

Cars View All
Find a Car
Jobs View All
Find a Job
Homes View All
Find a Home

Want to post a comment?

In order to join the conversation, you must be a member of Click here to register or to log in.