Court upholds Boseman adoption


The state Court of Appeals has upheld Sen. Julia Boseman's adoption of her former domestic partner's child.

A three-judge panel of the court unanimously agreed that Boseman's 2005 adoption of Melissa Jarrell's child cannot be undone. State law creates a nearly impossible hurdle for reversing completed adoptions, and to nullify the adoption and deny Boseman joint custody, Jarrell had challenged whether state law even allowed gay or lesbian parents to adopt.

"While [state law] does not specifically address same-sex adoptions, these statutes do make clear that a wide range of adoptions are contemplated and permitted, so long as they protect the minor’s 'needs, interests, and rights,'" Judge Wanda Bryant wrote in the opinion.

Bryant wrote that the court would have reached the same conclusion if the couple in question were heterosexual.

State law governing adoption does not specifically mention adoption by same-sex couples. Jim Lea, a domestic law specialist in Wilmington and one of Boseman's attorneys said that such adoptions have already been occurring. But the court opinion affirms the right of gay and lesbian couples to adopt.

"Now I think it's very clear that if a couple chooses to go out and adopt the child and execute the necessary waivers, that homosexual couples can adopt children," Lea said. "To say that a couple should not be able to adopt a child because they're gay, on that reason alone is just plain wrong."

Efforts to reach Jarrell's attorney Tuesday failed.

You must be logged in to post a comment on this blog. If you already have an N&O online user account, click here to log in. Otherwise, click here to register (it's free!).

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Re: Court upholds Boseman adoption

Too many children are being raised without a mother and a father. Women bring strenths and weakness into raising a child, as do men. So when you have 2 women, or 2 men raising a child, the child is missing out on the strengths of the opposite sex.

Re: Court upholds Boseman adoption

Wasn't the child growing up without a father anyway? I don't see why people object to same sex couples adopting. There is no shortage of kids that need families, and the fact is same sex couples communicate and resolve disagreements better than heterosexual couples.

Re: Court upholds Boseman adoption

"How does it suit a minor child's interests and needs to grow up without a father?"

The court has to deal with the facts at hand so your question is of no relevance.

Re: Court upholds Boseman adoption

How does it suit a minor child's interests and needs to grow up without a father?

Re: Court upholds Boseman adoption

Let's not stop there. Marijuana use by Boseman (raised by Jarrell) must be also considered legal and proper now in North Carolina too.* Not the Cicero of ancient Roman history

No doubt you are not aware that Cicero smoke Roman Pot while defending the liberty of the SPQR peoples, while the Roman establishment law and order freaks banished him to parts unknown in the Empire.....

Re: Court upholds marijuana use beneficial to children

"....... so long as they protect the minor’s 'needs, interests, and rights,'" Judge Wanda Bryant wrote in the opinion.

So Judge Bryant ruled that it was in this child's "needs, interests, and rights," to have Boseman as a parent.

Let's not stop there. Marijuana use by Boseman (raised by Jarrell) must be also considered legal and proper now in North Carolina too.

Re: Court upholds Boseman adoption

The saga continues...