Claims Dept: DSCC's 'Silence' ad on Dole

A new ad from the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee criticizes U.S. Sen. Elizabeth Dole for not taking a more active role on banking issues.

What the ad says: The ad shows a U.S. Senate seat with a sign reading "Elizabeth Dole, Wall Street." Images of trading floors and a couple looking at their monthly bills. "Our economy in meltdown. Elizabeth Dole. Six years on the banking committee. Sixty hearings. Silence. Not one question. Not one statement. But she was busy, raising $850,000 from Wall Street. But for us, she voted against helping families keep their homes. Newspapers called her "ineffective," "with Bush ... not North Carolinians." Elizabeth Dole, fighting for Wall Street — but what about us? The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee is responsible for the content of this advertising."

The background: The ad makes several claims about Dole's record.

BANKING COMMITTEE: Dole has served on the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs since 2003.

According to transcripts of committee hearings collected by the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, Dole did not ask any questions or make comments at 65 hearings held between Sept. 16, 2003, and July 29 of this year.

Dole spokesman Dan McLagan said the DSCC's list included some wrong committees and times when she was speaking on the Senate floor, but he would not give a detailed explanation.

"At first glance their list is riddled with errors," he said. "I am not going to devote staff time going through their list line-by-line."

FUNDRAISING: Dole has raised more than $900,000 from financial firms for her re-election.

According to campaign finance data collected by the Center for Responsive Politics, the Salisbury Republican has raised $906,905 from several different parts of the financial sector, including $270,985 from securities and investment firms, $247,377 from insurance companies, $242,075 from commercial banks and $146,468 from miscellaneous finance companies.

McLagan noted that those companies include North Carolina-based banks such as Wachovia, BB&T and Bank of America.

FORECLOSURES: Earlier this year, Congress considered a comprehensive bill reforming housing and mortgage regulations in order to address the rising number of foreclosures.

One version of the bill would have allowed bankruptcy judges to reduce the amount owed or changed the interest rate on a mortgage as part of a debt restructuring.

According to a Feb. 29 story in The New York Times, the Bush administration and Republican senators, including Dole, blocked the bill in a party-line vote to eliminate that and other provisions.

"That provision, supported by a wide range of consumer and civil rights groups, drew intense opposition from the mortgage industry, whose lobbyists argued that it would increase risks for lenders and drive up mortgage rates in the future," the Times wrote.

McLagan said the measure would have caused more problems than it solved.

"In a tight credit market, it would have tightened the market further," he said.

Dole voted against a measure in April to provide $100 million for foreclosure counseling, since the measure was not accompanied by an equivalent spending cut elsewhere in the budget.

NEWSPAPERS: Endorsing Democratic Senate candidate Kay Hagan, the Asheville Citizen-Times said Dole was not able to persuade her colleagues to tackle lending reforms.

"Though ... she was one of a handful of senators raising the alarm about the need for more oversight of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac for the last five years, she was ineffective in persuading her fellow senators to take action," the paper's editorial board wrote.

In its endorsement of Hagan, The Charlotte Observer said Dole had been ineffective generally.

"Dole should be a terrific senator," the paper's editorial board wrote. "That's why her ineffectiveness in representing North Carolina is such a surprise and such a disappointment."

The Winston-Salem Journal said in its endorsement of Hagan that Dole spent too much time on partisan issues.

"No one questions Dole's work ethic," the paper's editorial board wrote. "She's a vibrant woman. But while in Washington, Dole has reserved her best efforts for issues of importance to the national Republican Party and the Bush administration, not North Carolinians."

Is it accurate? Mostly. The claims quotes from newspapers are accurate. Most observers agree the measures Dole voted against would have helped homeowners, though there is disagreement on their negative effects. It is hard to gauge the truth about the claim about her silence at committee hearings, although it is clear she did not talk as much as other senators.