Claims Dept: Hagan's 'Crackdown' ad

ryanteaguebeckwith — Sat, 01 Nov 2008 16:20:35 -0400

In a new ad, Democratic Senate candidate Kay Hagan criticizes negative ads from Sen. Elizabeth Dole and notes her record on illegal immigration.

What the ad says: The ad shows images of Dole's ads and Hagan talking with law enforcement officers and voters. Narrator: "Now she's crossed the line. Newspapers are condemning Elizabeth Dole's shameful attacks. A lie born of Dole's desperation. Worse than dishonest. And now new lies about Kay Hagan's immigration record. The facts: Hagan voted to ban driver's licenses for illegal immigrants. Kay's been endorsed by 53 sheriffs, who know she's cracked down on a crisis Washington created. It's time for the truth. And a change." Hagan: "I'm Kay Hagan and I approve this message."

The background: The ad makes several claims about the Senate race.

EDITORIALS: Three major North Carolina newspapers wrote editorials chastizing Dole over a recent ad about Hagan's ties to a member of the Godless Americans PAC.

The Wilmington Star-News wrote that it was "shameful even by today's threshold for slime" and "smacks of desperation." The Charlotte Observer wrote that it was "a lie born of Dole's desperation in a race in which she has trailed for weeks."

And the Greensboro News-Record said it was "worse than dishonest" in depicting Hagan as "godless."

ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION: Starting in 2000, state Republicans pushed legislation to make it impossible for illegal immigrants to get driver's licenses.

The state Senate's Democratic leadership sent all of the bills to die in committee, but a provision in the 2001 budget made it slightly more difficult for illegal immigrants to get a license.

Other Republican bills died in committee over the next several years. In 2006, the House amended a Senate bill to make it impossible for illegal immigrants to get licenses.

Hagan voted for both bills, but she played only a supporting role in the process and did not intervene when earlier Republican measures were pushed aside.

She also cosponsored a 2008 bill requiring employers verify information on new employees and helped pass the 2007 budget, which included $750,000 to help promote a deportation program.

SHERIFFS: In late August, 53 of North Carolina's 100 sheriffs endorsed Hagan, according to the Associated Press. About two-thirds of the sheriffs are Democrats, and none of the Republican sheriffs endorsed her.

Is it accurate? It's overstated. It's true that Hagan voted to ban driver's licenses and supported other measures, but she hardly led a crackdown on illegal immigration. The claims about newspaper editorials and sheriff's endorsements are accurate.

— Ryan Teague Beckwith

Mailer targets Hagan on immigration

ryanteaguebeckwith — Fri, 17 Oct 2008 14:03:52 -0400

A mailer targets Democratic Senate candidate Kay Hagan on immigration.

The mailer, paid for by the state Republican Party on behalf of U.S. Sen. Elizabeth Dole's campaign, shows a picture of two Border Patrol agents frisking a man wearing suspenders and jeans.

"Liberal Kay Hagan Gave Driver's Licenses to Illegal Immigrants," it says.

Inside, the mailer argues that Hagan "blocked real illegal immigration reform in the State Senate" for nearly six years and "voted to allow illegal immigrants to get driver's licenses and joined other politicians to help kill tougher restrictions."

As noted previously, Senate Democrats sent legislation to toughen license standards to die in committee for several years. Though Hagan later voted to tighten standards and later for a total ban, it is fair to say that she blocked stronger efforts.

It's a little misleading to say that Hagan "gave driver's licenses" since they could already get them, but she did fail to take them away.

Document(s):
GOP-immigration.pdf