Nena Reeves, a Republican candidate for the state Senate District 12 seat in Johnston and Wayne counties, is criticizing David Rouzer, her opponent in the GOP primary, on immigration, Dan Kane reports.
What the ad says: "David Rouzer claims he shares our values. But he’s a D.C. lobbyist and stands with Ted Kennedy in support of amnesty for illegal immigrants. Called stealth amnesty by conservatives, David Rouzer’s bill is a backdoor for illegal aliens and their families. Illegal immigrants cost North Carolina taxpayers over $770 million a year. That’s wrong. Fortunately, we have Nena Reeves, proven leader, standing firm for our conservative values.”
What the ad looks like: A slightly out-of-focus picture of Rouzer wearing a dark suit and red tie appears. “Who is Lobbyist David Rouzer?” appears on the screen as his image expands. A red slash underlines “Lobbyist.” Then, a sharp picture of U.S. Sen. Ted Kennedy appears next to that of Rouzer. “D.C. Lobbyist for Ted Kennedy’s Amnesty Bill” appears on screen, citing a Tobacco Farm Quarterly article as the source.
The ad then cuts to a still of a border crossing with a “CAUTION” sign showing a silhouette of a man, woman and child running. “FREE Path for Family Members as well,” the screen says, citing the Heritage Foundation as the source.
Another still shows a rally with a woman dressed in a shirt resembling the U.S. flag. She is holding the U.S. flag and a sign that reads, “AMERICA HAS BEEN INVADED.” The shot then turns black-and-white, Rouzer’s color image is superimposed, again reminding viewers that he is “Lobbyist David Rouzer” with the red slash under “Lobbyist.” The screen reads: “ILLEGALS COST NC TAXPAYERS $771 Million,” citing the Federation for American Immigration Reform as the source. The ad ends with Reeves, busy at her desk.
The background: Rouzer, a Republican candidate in the 12th District, is a lobbyist. His clients include agribusinesses that favor passage of federal legislation they say would make the guest worker program more cost-effective. The program provides what are known as H-2A visas to foreigners to work temporary farm jobs such as picking crops. That legislation, which was co-sponsored by Kennedy, provides these workers with a path to U.S. citizenship if they can show they have worked for 150 days in the past two years. They would still have to work farm jobs for three more years and stay out of trouble before they could become U.S. citizens.
The Tobacco Farm Quarterly article refers to the debate over the legislation and quotes Rouzer’s advocacy. The Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank, has called the legislation “stealth amnesty.”
Is the ad accurate? It is based in truth, but it also exaggerates. Rouzer is a lobbyist, and he helped his clients try to get the legislation passed. But the ad suggests the legislation would open the door to all illegal immigrants. That’s not the case.
The ad accurately cites FAIR’s estimated cost to taxpayers, but it doesn’t mention that FAIR opposes amnesty efforts, and its cost estimate does not include how much illegal immigrants pay the state in sales and other taxes, or how much their in-state spending may boost North Carolina’s economy.